When someone at home says they care, but you always come away feeling worse
People who are sometimes warm and sometimes cutting raise your blood pressure more than people you openly dislike. How to spot it, and what to do.
Most of us picture harm as something that comes from strangers or open enemies. A lot of the harm to our health comes from much closer: a relative in the same house, an in-law, a brother or sister, a husband or wife, a flatmate, an old friend who is always around. Someone who says the right things in front of others and seems to care, and yet you always come away from them feeling smaller, more tired, more anxious and less sure of yourself.
Researchers call these relationships ambivalent. The person is both a source of support and a source of hurt, and you never quite know which one you will get. At the University of Utah, Julianne Holt-Lunstad and Bert Uchino gave healthy adults blood pressure monitors to wear for three days and took readings during their ordinary conversations. Blood pressure was lowest around supportive people. It went up around people they plainly disliked. It went up most of all around the people they felt mixed about. Later work by the same researchers has linked these relationships to more inflammation and faster ageing of the body's cells.
A study that followed more than 9,000 British civil servants for about 12 years found that people whose closest relationships were full of criticism, conflict and let-downs had a 34% higher risk of a heart attack or other heart problems, even after allowing for blood pressure, smoking and other risks.
Why the mixed ones hurt the most With an open enemy, your guard is up and you know where you stand. With someone who is sometimes kind, you lower your guard, you keep hoping, and you replay every remark wondering whether you imagined the sting. That constant watchfulness keeps the body's stress system switched on. Over months and years it shows up as poor sleep, headaches, acidity and stomach trouble, high blood pressure, low mood, anxiety, and a tiredness no tonic fixes. Most people never connect the two, because they are busy with work and family and the damage is quiet.
Signs worth noticing - You feel worse after time with them: drained, doubtful or on edge, even when nothing openly bad happened. - Their "concern" usually carries a dig, about your weight, your cooking, your earnings, your parenting or your choices. - Your good news is met with coolness, while your problems seem to cheer them up. - Your private matters reach other people, or get brought up in front of guests. - They discourage you from seeing a doctor or a therapist, question your medicines, or make you feel guilty for looking after your own health. - They slowly come between you and the people who support you. - When you raise something, you are told you are too sensitive, imagining things, or ungrateful, until you start doubting your own memory.
One sign on its own proves nothing. Families argue, people have bad days, and not every sharp remark comes from ill will. What matters is the pattern over months, and how your body and mind feel around that person.
What you can do 1. Keep a quiet note. For a few weeks, write down what happened and how you felt afterwards. Patterns you have learned to brush aside become clear on paper, and it ends the "you imagined it" doubt. 2. Share less. You don't owe anyone every detail. Keep plans, money matters, health issues and good news for people who have shown they can be trusted with them. 3. Set small boundaries, calmly. "I'm not going to discuss my weight." "I'll decide that with my doctor." Say it once, without a fight, and move on. 4. Keep charge of your own health. Hold your own reports, prescriptions and medicines, see the doctor you choose, and book your own appointments. 5. Keep your money and documents safe. Your own bank account, your own ID and property papers, your own phone passwords. 6. Stay close to the people who are good for you. One or two trusted friends or relatives outside the house make a big difference. Isolation is what lets this kind of harm grow. 7. Talk to a professional. A psychologist can help you see the situation clearly, deal with guilt and family pressure, and work out how much distance you need, without having to blow up your family life.
If it goes beyond words, if you are threatened, controlled, hurt or afraid for your safety, that is abuse, and help is there. The Women Helpline is 181. In an emergency, call 112. Tele-MANAS, the government's free 24-hour mental health line, is 14416.
Where this comes from - Holt-Lunstad J, Uchino BN, Smith TW et al. Social relationships and ambulatory blood pressure: structural and qualitative predictors of cardiovascular function during everyday social interactions. Health Psychology, 2003. - Holt-Lunstad J, Uchino BN. Social Ambivalence and Disease (SAD): A Theoretical Model Aimed at Understanding the Health Implications of Ambivalent Relationships. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 2019. - De Vogli R, Chandola T, Marmot MG. Negative Aspects of Close Relationships and Heart Disease. Archives of Internal Medicine, 2007.
Keep reading with a free account.
The full library is for Atulyam members. Sign up in a minute, or log in if you already have an account.
